Best Small Luxury Hotels in The Hamptons, USA

The Montauk Beach House, situated just off Route 27, offers guests an air-conditioned room with a flat-screen cable TV and a private bathroom with complimentary toiletries. For recreation, there is an outdoor swimming pool and lounge, as well as a DJ playing music every weekend. The hotel also has a gift shop offering clothing, beauty products and more. Free Wi-Fi is available throughout the hotel, and the front desk is open 24 hours a day. Dining options include a café and snack bar offering small plates and sandwiches, as well as the outdoor grill. Additionally, nearby South Edison is within walking distance. Camp Hero State Park and Hither Hills State Park are both within a short drive.

Rooms: 33 Stars: 5

Bridgehampton Inn opened in April 2019, offering guests a luxurious 5-star experience. Enjoy the garden, shared lounge, terrace, and restaurant, as well as a bar. The air-conditioned rooms come with free WiFi and private bathrooms, while the hotel is also allergy-free. Each room has a flat-screen TV and free toiletries. Guests can enjoy a sumptuous à la carte or continental breakfast. Located 24 km from Montauk Point Lighthouse, Second House Museum is 33 km away, and Hither Woods Preserve is 34 km away. Long Island MacArthur Airport is 72 km from the hotel.

Rooms: 12 Stars: 5

Experience the ultimate in luxury and relaxation at Haven Montauk in The Hamptons. This small boutique hotel is located in Montauk, close to Gin Beach and Theodore Roosevelt County Park. All rooms feature a TV and a private bathroom, with some offering a kitchenette and views of the ocean or Lake Montauk. Onsite amenities include a seasonal outdoor pool, fire pit, barbecue area and beach parking passes. Guests can take a short walk across the street to the bay, or explore 3.4 km away at Montauk Downs State Park, 8.8 km away at Montauk Point State Park, and 5 km away at Navy Park Road. Montauk train station and Block Island Ferry are also nearby.

Rooms: 27 Stars: 4

Montauk Manor offers a unique experience with on-site spa services and a range of activities to enjoy. Located in Montauk, New York, the property features an indoor and outdoor swimming pool, free Wi-Fi access, air conditioning, cable TV and a seating area in each room. There’s also a full kitchen with a dishwasher and microwave, and private bathrooms with free toiletries. Guests can make use of the spa and wellness centre, multiple tennis courts, meeting facilities and luggage storage. Horse riding and fishing are some of the activities available nearby, and a complimentary electric car charge is also provided. Kirk Park Beach is just 2.9 km away, and Montauk Museum is 10.1 km away.

Rooms: 110 Stars: 5

Experience luxury in The Hamptons at Baron’s Cove. This small hotel offers an on-site restaurant, seasonal saltwater swimming pool, free WiFi and free private parking. Relax in guest rooms equipped with flat-screen cable TVs, refrigerators and private bathrooms with bathrobes and free toiletries. Select rooms have views of the sea or garden. The 24-hour front desk provides clothing, accessories, and refreshments. Enjoy fresh American cuisine for lunch, dinner, breakfast and brunch. Bike hire is available and the area is great for cycling. Located in Sag Harbor, Mystic is 48 km away and Montauk is 29 km.

Rooms: 27 Stars: 4

Experience the East Hampton lifestyle at Journey East Hampton! Just 1.8 km away from Indian Wells Beach and Two Mile Hollow Beach, this hotel offers private parking, a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, a garden, and a shared lounge. All rooms come with a wardrobe, flat-screen TV, air conditioning, private bathroom, free toiletries, and bed linen and towels. Free WiFi is available. Enjoy a continental breakfast every morning! Journey East Hampton is also 11 km from Montauk Point Lighthouse, 20 km from Second House Museum, and 20 km from Hither Woods Preserve. The nearest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, 85 km away.

Rooms: 25 Stars: 4

The Inn at Southampton is an exquisite small luxury hotel located in the heart of The Hamptons. Surrounded by more than 5 acres of lush landscaped lawns, this Long Island hotel offers modern American cuisine with poolside service. Rooms are decorated with seashore themes and include free WiFi, cable TV, a refrigerator, and a work desk. Onsite Claude’s restaurant offers breakfast, brunch, and dinner with fresh, local ingredients. Guests can take advantage of the outdoor pool, tennis court, library, games room, and children’s play area. Enjoy a complimentary summer shuttle to Cooper’s Beach or explore nearby Southampton Golf Course and Morton National Wildlife Refuge. Experience the best of Long Island at the Inn at Southampton.

Rooms: 90 Stars: 4

Experience the luxury of a 19th century 4-star hotel at American Beech. Enjoy the free bikes, garden, restaurant and bar in Greenport. Located just 42 km from Splish Splash and 49 km from Second House Museum, this allergy-free hotel also offers free WiFi in all rooms, some with a city view. Start your day with a continental breakfast and explore the area’s cycling trails and nearby sites like Montauk Point Lighthouse and Hither Woods Preserve. Long Island MacArthur Airport is a 77 km drive away.

Rooms: 13 Stars: 4

Discover the perfect seaside getaway at our resort, nestled just 500 meters from the village of Montauk. With our private beach area, outdoor pool with sun terrace, and free Wi-Fi, you can relax and unwind in style. Our light rooms and studios feature soothing colors, a dining area, and a small refrigerator, while our air-conditioned Marram rooms are complete with wood furniture. Enjoy a walk along the beach or take a trip to Shadmoor State Park, The Terrace, Montauk Lighthouse, or Montauk Downs Golf and Recreation. With local stores, cafés, restaurants, and bars just a short distance away, you can enjoy a true taste of Montauk. Plus, our resort is completely screen-free, so you can unplug and enjoy a truly tranquil experience.

Rooms: 11 Stars: 4

Gurney’s Star Island Resort and Spa is situated on the picturesque Star Island in Lake Montauk. This Long Island resort offers luxurious accommodations with nautical-themed décor and private wooden balconies. Guests can relax on the private beach, take a dip in one of the three swimming pools, or rent a boat to explore the lake. Dining options include Showfish, The Pool Club and Il Forno. Spa services are also available. On-site activities include volleyball, lighted tennis courts, and horseshoe pits. Conveniently located nearby are Rita’s Horse Stables, the Montauk Downs Golf Course and the Montauk Point Lighthouse and Museum. Enjoy a relaxing stay at Gurney’s Star Island Resort and Spa.

Rooms: 102 Stars: 4